Select your country to view the content in your preferred language

Phone +44 1202 006012 • Monday to Friday from 8.30 am to 7 pm

An overview of PCB testing and inspection methods

An overview of PCB testing and inspection methods

PCB is the basic component of any electronic circuit, simple or complex it may be. The wide use of surface mount components (SMD), combined with the need for multiple layers, has inevitably increased the complexity of today’s PCBs. Regardless of the application, the common requirement that all PCBs must meet is to function correctly according to the project specifications and to be free from defects. The latest generation electronic circuits include hundreds of components with thousands of welds and interconnections: it is, therefore, essential to define rigorous inspection and test procedures, capable of ensuring the quality of the final product. As a result of the reduced time-to-market and high competition in many electronics fields, some electronic circuits might exit the prototyping stage with bugs or defects that shall be identified and resolved before the product reaches the final stage.

Overview of PCB testing

When electronic circuits were relatively simple, manual visual inspection (MVI) was sufficient to detect potential issues such as short circuits, imperfect solder joints, interrupted traces, reverted polarity of some components, or even missing components. However, the MVI technique was not without problems related to the mistakes made by humans in performing boring and repetitive operations. This has created situations in which defects were not detected or were at a very advanced stage of the design, in which modifications to the circuit had become too expensive. The next step was to automate the visual inspection process using the AOI (Automated Optical Inspection) technique. AOI is now a proven inspection method, widely used both during welding preflow and welding postflow, and available on several pick-and-place machines. The increasingly massive use of SMD components and BGA (Ball Grid Array) packages have highlighted the limitations of AOI, no longer able to detect the connections and welds hidden underneath the package. The AXI (Automated X-ray Inspection) technique was thus developed, based on the use of X-rays capable of not only seeing through the package but also of inspecting multi-layer PCBs with a high density of components. Once the inspection phase has passed, the PCB shall undergo an accurate test, performed on the completely assembled circuit.

Objective of PCB testing

A PCB is made up of different elements, each of which affects the overall performance of the electronic circuit. The minimum set of tests to be performed should include the following checks:

  • Electrical conductivity, including measurement of leakage currents;

  • Mechanical resistance;

  • Welds quality;

  • Cleanliness (weather resistance, including humidity and corrosion);

  • Quality of hole wall;

  • Lamination, which tests the laminate’s resistance to peeling by force or application of heat;

  • Copper plating, tested with tensile strength and analyzing the resulting elongation;

  • Environmental test, especially for PCBs which operate in humid environments;

  • Component polarity, orientation, alignment, and placement.

AOI

Being an inspection method, AOI can detect PCB faults or defects at early development stage. AOI is a visual inspection method which uses cameras to acquire images of the board from different angles and with different lighting conditions. This technique also integrates OCR functionality capable of interpreting the serigraphs on the PCB. Acquired images are then compared with what one would like to achieve (the so-called "golden board"). This method has the advantage of detecting different types of defects and can be used in several development stages. The main disadvantage is that of being limited to a line of sight control, not able to check connections hidden by BGA or other types of packages.

AXI

The high density introduced by SMT technology and the inability to identify connections in BGA and CSP (Chip Scale Package) packages, required more accurate inspection methods, such as those based on X-ray (AXI). Since welds are made with material whose atomic weight is higher than that of the other components on the board, they are clearly visible in the radiographic images. The main advantage of the AXI technique is that it detects all the connections and welds, even those hidden by the package; in addition, solder joints can also be inspected, highlighting the possible presence of bubbles. The chance of detecting any counterfeits of proprietary electronic components is also significant. On the other hand, AXI is a relatively expensive technique, the investment of which can be justified only for high density PCBs and components with BGA or CSP package. Figure 1 shows a defect detected by X-ray inspection.

PCB defect detected by X-ray inspection

Figure 1: PCB defect detected by X-ray inspection

In-circuit test (ICT)

This test, performed after the assembly stage, verifies the correct functioning and position of each electronic component on the PCB. The test includes verification of short circuits, open circuits, resistance, capacitance and other parameters. For this purpose, a flying probe is used, composed of an array of drivers and sensors that perform the measurements required by the test by moving freely on the board. The probe is controlled by appropriate software, which can be modified by adapting the same test system to boards with different layouts. Alternatively, a test fixture can be used, consisting of a bed of nails designed for the specific DUT (Device Under Test). Each "nail" behaves like a real sensor, able to electrically connect a specific point of the DUT to the test system. Bed-of-nails is an expensive and not very flexible technique (each board requires its own bed-of-nails); moreover, it shows some difficulties in testing boards with high component density, where spacing between pins is reduced. The ICT technique has the advantage of detecting several defects, relating to both the individual components and their connections, and can be performed without powering the board. Its disadvantage is related to the cost (complexity of both bed-of-nails and control software) and the inability to test the connectors, a significant limitation in analog and digital systems consisting of multiple cards. Figure 2 shows an ICT test machine with a flying probe.

ICT test with flying probe

Figure 2: ICT test with flying probe

A custom test fixture, prepared for the execution of the bed-of-nails test

Figure 3: A custom test fixture, prepared for the execution of the bed-of-nails test

Functional test

Functional test is the last step of the inspection and verification process. As the name implies, its task is to test the functioning of a circuit, reproducing the electrical signals capable of stimulating it and measuring the effects produced. The circuit is correctly powered and electrically stimulated through the interface connectors. A software application processes the measurements performed at suitable points on the PCB, verifying their correspondence with the design specifications. The advantage of the functional test is its ability to detect potential circuit anomalies that occur only when the circuit is powered; moreover, it is also able to measure the power absorption in specific points of the circuit. The disadvantages are related to the cost and complexity of the test system. In fact, it requires very sophisticated, but not much flexible, equipment, most of the time configured to perform only the test of a specific card.

Boundary-scan

Boundary-scan is a technique introduced to test the interconnections between the components on the board and is widely used to test ICs when it is not possible to reach all the nodes of the circuit. The physical probes are replaced by "cells", whose output (TDO) and input (TDI) data pins are connected in sequence to suitable shift registers and to a circuitry for multiplexing. The boundary scan logic is timed by a TCK (Test Clock) signal, while a TMS (Test Mode Select) signal enables the test. It is thus possible to access the I/Os without having to place physical test points on the board, through a simple 4-wire serial interface (which becomes 5 if an optional reset signal is included) called TAP (Test Access Port). The Boundary Scan Description Language (BSDL) files, provided by manufacturers, contain information on boundary-scan components. The boundary scan method has the advantage of being suitable for several applications, including system-level test, RAM and flash memory test and CPU emulation. In addition, the test can be conducted directly on the field. On the other hand, its main disadvantage is that it is not an exhaustive test, the coverage of which is limited to the components which support this type of interface.

Conclusion

Regardless of which method is chosen, PCB testing represents a fundamental step in the electronic design process, able to save a lot of time and money, identifying possible defects affecting the circuit before it reaches final production. In general, an appropriate combination of the inspection and test methods mentioned above is able to detect all possible defects, with variable costs depending on the specific application and complexity of the circuit under test.

maurizio-paolo-emilioBy M. Di Paolo Emilio

Maurizio holds a Ph.D. in Physics and is a telecommunication engineer and journalist. He has worked on various international projects in the field of gravitational-wave research. He is Editor-in-chief of Power Electronics News. He is the author of several books published by Springer, as well as numerous scientific and technical publications on electronics design.

 

Share this Protonews:

Order your electronic boards prototypes in just a few clicks!

Start your project